The use of mobile applications to track one's behavior and thoughts may be beneficial for a variety of patients suffering from anxiety and depression. These applications use "quantified self" tools to track one's behaviours and cognitions. Therapists can access the collected data to measure a patient's progress and effectiveness. Many of these apps allow users to share this information with therapists. As the popularity of these apps increases, more are being developed.
Limitations of study on mental health apps
A recent review of 100 mental health apps found that only 14 were clinically validated. This result highlights the difficulty of evaluating the effectiveness of these services because they focus on promising apps rather than large scale clinical trials. While the majority of apps are likely to be valuable for some patients, their lack of long-term retention is a problem. While this problem is not unique to mental health apps, it is a significant problem across the board. The low cost of entry means that most app developers simply cannot afford to conduct a clinical trial.
While a study from the University of Liverpool shows that these apps can be effective for certain users, it also points to a problem: the lack of clinical observation and assessment of the effectiveness of these apps. In some instances, users may be self-diagnosing. As such, mental health treatment requires a more comprehensive approach than logging onto a mobile app. A study by the Anxiety and Depression Association of America, however, suggests that reliance on mental health apps may reduce the willingness to seek professional help.
The most troubling limitation of the study is the lack of specialized mental health apps. A quick search on the app store for "mental health apps" will turn up very few results. A user will need to sift through a sea of apps that are irrelevant or even stigmatizing. It is not clear whether this study will have any real-world impact on the development of mental health apps. The study did not address how to design mental health apps that do this effectively.
Impact of mental health apps on indirect outcomes
In an effort to understand the impact of mental health apps on both direct and indirect outcomes, researchers conducted a secondary analysis of dozens of existing studies. Members from the US, UK, and Australia conducted the studies and developed conclusions based on their findings. The study's results demonstrate the importance of incorporating data-driven methods for early diagnosis and intervention. These methods can help clinicians identify a patient's need for treatment before a crisis occurs, allowing them to intervene before it becomes a crisis.
One of the biggest barriers to mental health app adoption is a lack of transparent and visible reimbursement mechanisms. Currently, many mental health apps are funded through confidential one-time contracts that prevent potential app vendors from seeing the financial pay-off they'd expect from selling their products. Additionally, different countries fund their health services differently, so there is little evidence that international reimbursement mechanisms would be sufficient to cover the cost of these apps.
While these apps don't address the root causes of a mental health problem, they can make access to these treatments more convenient. One example is Big White Wall, which lets patients complete cognitive behavioral therapy online. The service was endorsed by the U.K. government-funded National Health Service. Sun also notes that the vast majority of Big White Wall users improved their symptoms, despite the lack of personal contact. This study highlights the potential of technology for mental health care.
Impact of mental health apps on treatment of anxiety and depression
In this meta-analysis, researchers determined the effect of mental health apps on anxiety and depression symptoms in smartphone users. The studies compared the effects of smartphone apps versus a control group, and depressive symptoms were measured using a variety of tools, including the Depression Anxiety Stress Scale (DASS), the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9), and the Beck Depression Inventory II scale. In addition, smartphone apps improved mood significantly only in mild-to-moderate depression, but had no effect on major depression. Bipolar disorder and other anxiety disorders were not impacted.
Mental health apps are also helping people overcome the social stigma associated with seeking treatment. Research has shown that more people suffer from anxiety disorder than seek therapy, and the number one reason for not seeking treatment is because they want to solve their problems on their own. While mental health apps may not be the answer for every person, they can still be an effective tool for many people. However, it is important to remember that not all mental health apps are scientifically proven to improve mood or anxiety symptoms. Hence, it is crucial to find apps based on research principles or independent studies that have good user feedback.
A large survey of mobile health apps found that users are more likely to adopt mHealth interventions than those that are not. The reasons for this are varied. The costs, privacy concerns, and workforce issues have been identified as common barriers for adoption. However, it appears that the benefits of these apps may outweigh the potential risks. They may even be able to improve the quality of life for users. They may also be beneficial for a wide range of other disorders, such as phobias, which are often overlooked in clinical practice.